I can't answer to the toys as my dogs have always liked toys. They will not fetch or bring things back, but they like soft toys and squeaky toys. Sometimes they don't show a lot of interest, but I leave their toys in a basket and if I put them all away I notice they get them back out. But to Hollee, I have had luck with the treats. My dogs are picky with treats and they have NEVER eaten a dry dog bone in their life. They take them off and then I find them around the house, untouched. So I just KNEW there was no way they would eat the treats that came with this box. They were coconut flavored dry dog biscuits. The jerky also looked a bit on the dry side. Both are all natural, you can understand all the ingredients, no fillers. My dogs LOVED them. They wanted more jerky immediately after gulping down their first piece and then they ate the dry dog treats right away. I couldn't believe it. So it was a definite win on the treats.