The color I purchased wasn't available to choose (it was the dark brown shade) and I was slightly disappointed with the lack of anything remotely resembling glimmer, shimmer, sparkle, etc. Maybe I misunderstood when I ordered it but I was under the impression that it would have some sort of sparkle or shine. Like a subtle glitter liner. I first swatched it on my hand and there was a little sparkle (like very little) but once I put it on my eyes there was none. With that being said it was actually a really great eyeliner. Went on smooth, very pigmented, and lasted all day!! Besides the disappointment from the lack of shimmer I was pretty happy with it. I only took off one star because the eyeliner was that great and all the other pros kind of canceled out that one con. Overall I was pretty happy with my purchase.