I like the idea of this eyeliner more then I like it in real life. It's a great value, but I personally don't like the way it looks on my eye. I have green eyes, and I used the black one. It looked decent but I prefer more matte eyeliners. Also, if your looking for a liner that doesn't smudge very easily don't pick this... Maybe my skin is oily, but after 4 hours I ended up looking like a raccoon. That's WITH primer and setting spray! Might work for other people, but definitely didn't work for me.