I received this in my ipsy bag. It's a great eyeliner. Very precise thin line. I love felt tip eyeliners but sometimes I feel like the tips dry out, this one was loaded with product so I had no trouble getting a nice even dark line. Perfect for a nice sharp wing. Definitely smudge proof but not really water proof (which I actually like, I hate how hard waterproof items can be to remove ) this is a great product.