Before turning to liquid-based eyebrow products, I would solely use Anastasia's Perfect Brow Pencils. It matched perfectly with my brow color and was easy to draw with. It created a very natural look and lasted all day. Not a fan of the price, but if you only use brow pencils, I suggest trying this one out.

My brows are not particularly full or shapely, but you wouldn’t know it, because I use this GOAT eyebrow pencil! It goes on smoothly and lasts a long time. I barely feel it on my face, but I know it’s still there. This pencil is a “must buy”!

I feel like brow pencils last longer than other brow products. And this Anastasia brow pencil makes my brows look natural when I apply it. It doesn’t smudge especially that my brows tend to get oily around.