I prefer the Anastasia powder. The benefit product doesn't have a great shade range, plus one part of it has a waxy texture, which I'm not a fan of. The Anastasia powder is a bit longer lasting than the Benefit, although I barely can see a difference there... The main reason why I prefer the Anastasia is simply the way that it looks on my brows. When I wear it people compliment how nice my natural brows look instead of complimenting the makeup. Anyway, it's up to personal preference... I would try them out for yourself so that you can see what works best for you :) Good luck!