It depends on what color scheme you want, the tartelette in bloom has many more cool toned colors and the modern Renaissance is extremely warm toned. I own both and think they are both amazing palettes but I prefer the modern Renaissance because it can do more and has more colorful options. The quality is amazing on both of them so it really comes down to color selection and how versatile you want the palette to be. In my opinion, the modern renaissance can create pretty much every look that the tartelette in bloom can, but tartelette in bloom can't create every look the modern Renaissance can if that makes sense. Hope this helped!