Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

Amish Wedding Old Fashioned Strawberry Butter

Amish Wedding Old Fashioned Strawberry Butter

BY AMISH WEDDING #4 in Jams & Jellies

4.5 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars68%
  • 4 Stars21%
  • 3 Stars8%
  • 2 Stars2%
  • 1 Star0%
4.55 / 5 based on 282 Reviews

Top Questions See all 498 Q&A

Amish Wedding Old Fashioned Strawberry Butter
Amish Wedding Old Fashioned Strawberry Butter
Reviews (282)
Q&A (92)
Leave a Review
Cassie C.
Rochester, NY
318 reviews
This stuff is so yummy! Its amazing on a bagel or English muffin for breakfast! I really love strawberries so this is perfect. It has a good texture and isn't overly sweet, it doesn't taste like someone loaded sugar in it either. I would recommend.
Ciara C.
Evans, GA
127 reviews
Tried a sample of this awhile bake and I have to say I was pleasantly surprised. Not too sweet at all. But I didn't think it tasted a lot of strawberry. Not too how how to really explain it. I did not but any as I didn't know where I got the sample from
Chelsea W.
Rome, GA
125 reviews
Never had strawberry butter. Love strawberries though and apple butter. Had Pumpkin as well it was shocking good. The smell was awful. Curious if this smells like it taste and vice versa like the pumpkin butter did
Katie S.
140 reviews
So delicious! This butter is so rich in flavor and goes well on just about anything! I put it on English muffins, which is absolutely delicious! For the price, it has a lot inside of the jar! Very much worth it!
Kayla W.
Mobile, AL
13 reviews
If you're looking for little gifts for your wedding guests that they'll remember forever. This is the stuff to use! I recommend putting it in smaller mason jars with some ribbon or a flower around it to add a special touch!
Katelyn C.
Adamsville, AL
164 reviews
So so so yummy!! I'm a sucker for anything strawberry!! This stuff is awesome!! It's so good on toast in the mornings!!! I definitely would recommend this!! You don't be disappointed! I will buy again!
Makalia M.
Telford, TN
22 reviews
I ordered this about a week ago and tried it! We considered giving it as a wedding favor but aren't sure it will be as budget friendly as we would like to accommodate 100 guests. The taste is great! I just wish it was a bit less in price.
Danielle B.
Piney Flats, TN
118 reviews
This sounds absolutely wonderful. Amish food is always great because they take the time & care to make it great. Lots of unique stuff. No doubt this is wonderful
Quiana H.
Sumter, Sc
233 reviews
This is a very tasty buttery jelly. It is great on toast and bagels. It tastes great and delicious. It is affordable and convenient. I love the strawberry flavor.
Aly P.
Lexington, KY
70 reviews
Love this strawberry butter! Light but full of flavor, and can be used in many different recipes or just as an easy tasty spread. I usually make my own speciality items, but this is worth the price and quality.
Kayla B.
Newport News, VA
241 reviews
Would you try this? Yay or Nay?
Rozalynne O.
Johnston, SC
58 reviews
What's the best thing to eat this on?
Jenny V.
Portland, OR
187 reviews
Who would want to eat old fashion strawberry butter?
Cheyenne P.
153 reviews
Is it like apple butter?
Elsy O.
Phelan, CA
118 reviews
Has anyone tried it ? Lol

Sign up to join our community!



influenster cashback

Please confirm your email address.

6 characters minimum. Password must consist of letters, at least 1 number and 1 special character.