I have been using this product for awhile, and I like the concealer. The tone is good and it is the right shade/consistency for an under eye concealer. However, I do NOT like the packaging at all, which is why I am giving it three stars and not four. The little brush at the end is pointless and I don't think anyone would use it. I have re-purchased this product twice after finishing my initial tube. First tube- didn't use the brush, but no problems squeezing the product onto my skin so that I could apply it with my own concealer brush. Second tube, the tube split when I tried squeezing it. Third tube-the tube still split but I am able to use it. I just get the product out from the crack where it split. These packaging flaws are totally avoidable. After I use up this tube, I will probably switch to a different product.