I received this palette in a subscription box, and it arrived with one of the shadows completely crushed. There is a lot of fallout when you simply tap your brush in the matte formulas because they are so soft. However they blend nicely and layer well. The shimmer shadows are hit and miss the shades with the fine shimmer have great colour pay off / the more glitter style seem to have that ‘rubbed to many times’ finish in them now and don’t pick up well on a finger or a brush. I am glad I tried the brand and the palette but I would not repurchase.