S’mores are a close second to the Thin Mints. They are a unique cookie sandwich that gives you a nice twist on the classic smore. They have a smooth filling and nice cookie base. They stay in tact since they are packaged in a plastic tray. Overall a good second place cookie.

S’mores are my new favorite Girl Scout cookie right after Thin Mints, my old life-long favorite! I buy Girl Scout cookies from 2 different GS’s each year. When the S’mores came out, I noticed both troupes sold different versions of the cookie so of course I tried both. (I was told that different regional kitchens make their own version of the cookies). My picture shows both versions. The first is two oval shaped cookies with a thin layer of chocolate and marshmallow in between. The second is a larger square cookie with a layer of marshmallow filling entirely covered in chocolate. Both are great cookies, however, the chocolate lover in me prefers the chocolate covered version. Unfortunately, I can’t find these cookies any longer, but I won’t soon forget them. As I said, both are great but the chocolate covered are excellent and worth the extra dollar they charged!!

These are the wrong ones but I couldn’t find these. I thought being brownies they’d be softer, they weren’t. They were still very good. Chocolate with (non gooey) caramel in it. Not my favorite but still good