I really like this mascara. It wears well, applies easily and looks great. Not all waterproof mascaras hold up well, and a number of them clump and flake. My only complaint may not affect others. I often find that by evening time, my eyelashes are itching and I am rubbing my eyes. Of course, this just reinforces the importance of having a facial cleansing routine morning and evening. If you don't want a struggle, you will need a good oil-free eye makeup remover.