Eye liner is pretty good . Goes on smooth. Has good precision. Fine line tip -wings out a good cat eye look but not anything spectacular in my book. The mascara, was a tad disappointing. The formula was a bit thinner than expected or that I would prefer. What I paid for a mini size- was a little much. Had i known the mascara was not up to my par, I would have been happier going to Walgreens and spending $10 bucks on a fullsize tube of Loreal Voluminus.
I absolutely fell in love the first time I used this a year ago. I used other cleansers like I always do, trying to find that one holy grail. I recently decided to come back to this and do not regret! BOTTOM LINE Yes, I would recommend this to a friend