I apply this liner at 8 AM and it is still on when I come home at 8 PM! No smudging no running, nothing! It is a little difficult to sharpen but I was told to use the sharpener that is sold by the company itself and I would have no issues.
This product came in a multipackaged set from Kiehls. It's very liquidy and not thick like a cream at all. Although liquidy, it is absorbed quickly and moisturizes well. I also use the toner along with the face lotion and have seen great results!