I'm really surprised with this product, it is a true black eyeliner; I also have it in blue. Very easy to use. Wears beautifully and doesn't move around. The applicator is very versatile, allows for you to create thin to thicker lines very easy.
I'm in love with this palette. The colors are great, very pigmented, not powederly, easy to work with and give you the option of creating natural to electric looks. Also, whoever is interested in purchasing this palette please be patient and check on ulta's specials. I got mine for only $19.00 at ulta.