i looovvvee the packaging for these shadows. it's so unique!!! the shadows are pretty good too and i personally love the shade selection because it makes my green eyes pop. but the shadows for me were kinda chalky and were a little blochy but they blended out with a good transition shade
i like to tight line my eyes and this eyeliner is the only eyeliner that will stay in place all day. i usually use the black on. It is totally worth the price!!! in this case, i wouldn't go searching for a dupe, i would splurge on the eyeliner for sure.