To me this is the best eyeliner. It is so SOO pigmented, I've just used the black one but I'm pretty sure the other colors are as pigmented as the black one. I want to try them all. Good price for a good eyeliner.
Ok, it was so good at first. This was one of my first brushes, maybe that's why I thought it was so good. But then, after trying the wet n wild ones I realized how wrong I was... This doesn't blend anything, the brush is so hard... If you want drugstore brushes for your eyes then try the wet n wild ones. The elf's brushes for the face are very good though.
I haven't used any other drugstore palette because I got very impressed with this one that I don't want to try a new one! I love the contour, I like to use both of the colors and it looks perfect. The banana color is perfect to set my concealer. The only reason I don't give it 5 stars is because of the shimmery shadow, I think is a highlighter (actually I don't know what's that shadow) but doesn't last at all... But besides that, the palette is perfect for contouring.
Awesome for oily lids! Your eyeshadow stays all day and it makes it blend very well. I've never tried the urban decay one but a lot of people say it's a good dupe. The only reason I don't give it 5/5 is because it gets dry very fast, you have to blend it well or it will be a mess. I recommend to use just a tiny amount of product.