I'll admit, I'm shocked at how much I liked this. I received the 2 in 1 (shampoo + conditioner) from @influenster as part of a product testing campaign. First the pluses, it was lathery and moisturizing, I still used my regular conditioner after because I needed to, I have super long and dry hair. It smelled AMAZING. Not like a typical dandruff shampoo at all. And most of all it WORKED. After just a couple uses my scalp wasn't itchy at all. (Yay). I don't think the negatives necessarily reflect the product, but I'll say the 2 in 1 probably wasn't right for me. Not moisturizing enough to use alone, and washed out a LOT of my hair color (artificial).