I can’t necessarily say this doesn’t work it just didn’t work for me. I feel like if you don’t use powder to set your face then this may work for you. I on the other hand have to use powder and this kinda just smeared everything.
My go to cheap liquid eyeliner! Stays on all day and doesn’t fade. I refuse to carry the expensive brands when I’m traveling and this stuff does the trick without me worrying about wasting money if I were to lose my name brand liners.