This is definitely a pigmented, strong neutral palette. However, unfortunately many dupes have come out since. Since the Naked palette was so popular, tons of cheaper brands have given it their own try and many have succeeded. Because of that, the Naked palette is still great but other brands have similar products that are cheaper now so it's no longer worth your money.
Nars makes gorgeous products, no lie. And this is no exception. However, Nars is a particularly expensive brand and paying so much money for one pencil liner isn't necessary. Save money on eyeliner by buying drug store and splurge when it comes to other Nars products, like foundation or lipstick.