The eyeliner was OK and the application was decent the problem that I had with it was that there was only enough product to line my eyes 2-3 times. I'm not a heavy eye liner user but it just seemed like there was almost nothing in it.
This is what I buy for my cat. He only eats meow mix. This food is definitely super affordable too. I only wish it was a little more healthy/less processed with more nutritious ingredients and less fillers.