If I wanted a waterproof mascara, I would have bought one stating it was waterproof. This was absolutely the worst mascara in history. I couldn't get it off no matter what I tried. Coconut oil, oil based make up remover (2 different ones), make up wipes, water and soap... And NOTHING. I don't even care how it makes my eyelashes look if I can't even get it off. I've probably lost all of my eyelashes now trying to get it off. Scrub it off actually. Never again and will be getting my money back from this crap.
Leaves a film on my skin after use. Doesn't make me feel clean like their other products. I keep it around for the "just in case" factor if I run out of something else and need it right then and there. Not really something I would recommend.