Top-Rated Cream Eyeliners

Based on 672,960 Influenster Reviews

Smooth lines with precise flicks? You have to use a cream eyeliner for your next cat eye. Cream eyeliners are silky smooth and allow you to line your eyes with precision. Unlike gel eyeliners, cream eyeliners give a softer and more natural look–perfect for a toned-down makeup look.

Take a look at the top cream eyeliners, and let us know which one you love in the comments below! 

Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByBeatriz C.said...
I bought this eyeliner in black, zero, directly from UD. I love their products, especially their 24/7 eyeliners but I use this now daily and may never return to another eyeliner. It is so easy to put on and extremely precise. As otherwise noted it also does last. Not to mention, you use very little at a time to get the desired effect AND no pulling on your eyes! It really is worth every penny. If you buy this you will not be disappointed.
I bought this eyeliner in black, zero, directly from UD. I love their products, especially their 24/7 eyeliners but I use this now daily and may never return to another eyeliner. It is so easy to put on and extremely precise. As otherwise noted it also does last. Not to mention, you use very little at a time to get the desired effect AND no pulling on your eyes! It really is worth every penny. If you buy this you will not be disappointed.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByCrystal B.said...
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have never used a cream eyeliner until I bought this one I usually use a pencil and I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it is to apply and how little you have to use to get a hold look. I have been telling everyone I know about Lorac and how amazing their products are.
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have never used a cream eyeliner until I bought this one I usually use a pencil and I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it is to apply and how little you have to use to get a hold look. I have been telling everyone I know about Lorac and how amazing their products are.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByElizabeth C.said...
I LOVE THIS STUFF. I started buying this eye liner about 4 years ago. And I will never go back to my old eye liner. The brush is much more precise than an eyeliner pen. It also lasts way longer. I had this stuff for over 6 months without running out. Occasionally I just skimmed off the top layer and added a few drops of contact solution and washed the brush to make sure it wasn't getting gross. And it was as good as new. This eyeliner is amazing. I will never go back to eye liner pens.
I LOVE THIS STUFF. I started buying this eye liner about 4 years ago. And I will never go back to my old eye liner. The brush is much more precise than an eyeliner pen. It also lasts way longer. I had this stuff for over 6 months without running out. Occasionally I just skimmed off the top layer and added a few drops of contact solution and washed the brush to make sure it wasn't getting gross. And it was as good as new. This eyeliner is amazing. I will never go back to eye liner pens.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
ByShawna M.said...
I love this eyeliner. I have never used anything other than pencil eyeliner before. I received this as a free gift with purchase from e.l.f. and i was very hesitant. Potted eyeliners intimidate me. I goofed around and started playing with it and different eyeliner brushes that I have, and It just works wonderfully. You will not get a perfect line the first time through. You will have to build this, but once built, the line is dramatic and beautiful. I am just over the moon with this product.
I love this eyeliner. I have never used anything other than pencil eyeliner before. I received this as a free gift with purchase from e.l.f. and i was very hesitant. Potted eyeliners intimidate me. I goofed around and started playing with it and different eyeliner brushes that I have, and It just works wonderfully. You will not get a perfect line the first time through. You will have to build this, but once built, the line is dramatic and beautiful. I am just over the moon with this product.
Member Photos & Videos (2)
Highlighted Review
ByTali G.said...
Wow this eyeliner is probably the best one I've used so far. It was recommended to me by a friend because I can not - for the life of me - skill the winged liner look (beginnerssss hah) and she got me into this cream eyeliner and brush technique which works wonders for me!!!! The best part? Stays on FOR HOURS. definitely should give it a try :)
Wow this eyeliner is probably the best one I've used so far. It was recommended to me by a friend because I can not - for the life of me - skill the winged liner look (beginnerssss hah) and she got me into this cream eyeliner and brush technique which works wonders for me!!!! The best part? Stays on FOR HOURS. definitely should give it a try :)