The Top-Rated Vanilla Ice Cream

Based on 284,252 Influenster Reviews

Know what time it is? Ice cream time! Influensters everywhere love to indulge their sweet tooth tendencies. With more than 182K reviews, these are the best-tasting vanilla ice cream flavors. Pair it with a brownie, pie, root beer—or enjoy solo. Vanilla is the new chocolate, according to these Influensters!

Which vanilla ice cream is your go-to when your sweet tooth hits? Share below!

Highlighted Review
ByStephanie N.said...
This is my favorite vanilla ice cream at the grocery store. It is so creamy and has the perfect amount of vanilla flavor. The only con is that the package is so small! Would love them to sell a half gallon!
This is my favorite vanilla ice cream at the grocery store. It is so creamy and has the perfect amount of vanilla flavor. The only con is that the package is so small! Would love them to sell a half gallon!
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByAlana C.said...
I love Häagen-Dazs and this ice cream is no difference. This vanilla is delightfully creamy and rich with its little flecks of vanilla bean. The only downside is that this ice cream can get pretty pricey.
I love Häagen-Dazs and this ice cream is no difference. This vanilla is delightfully creamy and rich with its little flecks of vanilla bean. The only downside is that this ice cream can get pretty pricey.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByJeannie C.said...
Blue Bunny has the MOST creamy texture of all ice creams! I don't like my ice cream to have an icy texture, this is smooth. Vanilla flavor is so versatile. A yummy flavor to which many types of toppings can be added to accommodate each personal taste when having a group of people over. Always my first choice to purchase because I know all my guests will love it as much as I love it!
Blue Bunny has the MOST creamy texture of all ice creams! I don't like my ice cream to have an icy texture, this is smooth. Vanilla flavor is so versatile. A yummy flavor to which many types of toppings can be added to accommodate each personal taste when having a group of people over. Always my first choice to purchase because I know all my guests will love it as much as I love it!
Member Photos & Videos (3)
Highlighted Review
ByBreyonna S.said...
I absolutely love this ice cream from Breyers. It is honestly one of my favorite vanilla flavored ice creams and I'm super picky. A lot of ice creams have a very fake and artificial vanilla flavor but this one doesn't. It tastes like how vanilla should and it honestly has such a taste difference its surprising. It's also super creamy and delicious.
I absolutely love this ice cream from Breyers. It is honestly one of my favorite vanilla flavored ice creams and I'm super picky. A lot of ice creams have a very fake and artificial vanilla flavor but this one doesn't. It tastes like how vanilla should and it honestly has such a taste difference its surprising. It's also super creamy and delicious.