The Best Store-Bought Pies Around

Based on 21,331 Influenster Reviews

Is there ever a bad time for pie? We don't think so! And with so many ready-made and frozen pie brands to choose from, it's easy to enjoy your favorites, just defrost, bake and slice – or in some cases just take a bite! So, how is it possible to choose the best frozen pies around when taste is so subjective? Is it, though? Influensters have left thousands of reviews and there seems to be a consensus.

Here's a list of the best frozen pies to pick up at the grocery store when in a pinch or just in the mood for something sweet as recommended by Influensters.

 

Highlighted Review
ByLaleña J.said...
You could say I love pumpkin pie. Love doesn't quite capture it though. This pie makes my dreams come true. You bake it, and you feel like it's homemade, and then a can of whipped cream, and you're in heaven. This pie is worth every penny. God I love it. Thanksgiving is made better because of Sara Lee
You could say I love pumpkin pie. Love doesn't quite capture it though. This pie makes my dreams come true. You bake it, and you feel like it's homemade, and then a can of whipped cream, and you're in heaven. This pie is worth every penny. God I love it. Thanksgiving is made better because of Sara Lee
Member Photos & Videos (2)
Highlighted Review
ByTammy H.said...
By far these are my favorite pies, beats any of the others I've tried. The cherry flavor is right on point with a little bit of tartness. love it.
By far these are my favorite pies, beats any of the others I've tried. The cherry flavor is right on point with a little bit of tartness. love it.
Highlighted Review
Bykassy J.said...
I love these tastykake pies! They are some of the best around. I ate them growing up living in PA and always stock up when I go back home for a visit! The crust is perfect and it's filled with a new juicy fruit filling. The lemon has the perfect amount of tartness without being to sweet!
I love these tastykake pies! They are some of the best around. I ate them growing up living in PA and always stock up when I go back home for a visit! The crust is perfect and it's filled with a new juicy fruit filling. The lemon has the perfect amount of tartness without being to sweet!
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByCassie B.said...
This Banana Cream Pie is DIVINE!! I'm usually not a huge fan of Banana Cream Pie (LOVE the banana flavor, not so much the mushy banana slices in most pies), but this pie was refreshingly delicious! It is light and not overpoweringly sweet, and it has just the right amount of banana flavor without all those mushy banana slices! We always stock up on this Pie when Fry's does their annual sale before Thanksgiving.
This Banana Cream Pie is DIVINE!! I'm usually not a huge fan of Banana Cream Pie (LOVE the banana flavor, not so much the mushy banana slices in most pies), but this pie was refreshingly delicious! It is light and not overpoweringly sweet, and it has just the right amount of banana flavor without all those mushy banana slices! We always stock up on this Pie when Fry's does their annual sale before Thanksgiving.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByShana S.said...
Edwards has THE BEST pre-made key lime pie. It is so smooth, and the perfect mix of sweet and sour. It has a lot of calories so if you are looking for something lite, this isn't what you want. If you're looking for a dessert everyone can enjoy on Thanksgiving, this is the one you want!
Edwards has THE BEST pre-made key lime pie. It is so smooth, and the perfect mix of sweet and sour. It has a lot of calories so if you are looking for something lite, this isn't what you want. If you're looking for a dessert everyone can enjoy on Thanksgiving, this is the one you want!
Highlighted Review
ByRena S.said...
Always a favorite. My husband loves these especially. I can't always eat the entire crust but the part with the filling is delicious. They have a crispy crust that doesn't get all gooey but the filling is a chunky apple pie filling type that is sooo good. They are super sweet. I don't think anyone should eat these on a regular basis. Just as a yummy treat.
Always a favorite. My husband loves these especially. I can't always eat the entire crust but the part with the filling is delicious. They have a crispy crust that doesn't get all gooey but the filling is a chunky apple pie filling type that is sooo good. They are super sweet. I don't think anyone should eat these on a regular basis. Just as a yummy treat.