The fact that this is oil- free is great. I have used another makeup remover before that was pure oil, if I used it to touch up mascara mistakes, it would stay on my skin and continuously remove the mascara from my eyelashes throughout the day- it didn't look good, so I'm skeptical about using another makeup remover containing oil. THIS ONE works great, and my sister uses it as well and likes it (she uses a lot more eye makeup than I do, so I take that as a good thing). It's great because it gets the job done, without over-drying the skin or irritating it, it doesn't stick to your skin, it lasts a long time. The product is made of 2 liquids, so you have to shake the bottle to mix the 2 before you use it, so that it removes the makeup- just remember this and you'll be fine!