The Best Nut Butters: 16K Reviews

Based on 15,827 Influenster Reviews

When you need a quick snack that's full of protein and healthy fats, nut butters are a great option. But not all nut butters are made equally. We've rounded up top rated nut butters for when you want to spread it, make Pad Thai, dip it, put it on ice cream or eat it by itself!

What's your favorite way to enjoy the tasty spread?

Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
ByVeronica M.said...
This is my favorite brand of peanut butter. I love the rich flavor and smooth texture. This is a must have for me and really gets lots of use around the holidays. I love making peanut butter pie and homemade peanut butter cookies as well as peanut butter between two cracker and dipped in chocolate during the holidays! I highly recommend this brand for every day and baking needs.
This is my favorite brand of peanut butter. I love the rich flavor and smooth texture. This is a must have for me and really gets lots of use around the holidays. I love making peanut butter pie and homemade peanut butter cookies as well as peanut butter between two cracker and dipped in chocolate during the holidays! I highly recommend this brand for every day and baking needs.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
ByJessica M.said...
When a co-worker first brought PB2 into work to share with us all, I have to admit I was skeptical and hesitant and thought she was a bit crazy. In just a couple of minutes though she had whipped us up a bit of the PB2 to try and I was hooked immediately. I am a huge peanut butter fan, HUGE - but because I am cautious about my caloric intake eating the regular PB isn't always the best option. Plus in some of these peanut butters you don't know what you are getting as far as ingredients go. The things that I love about PB2 is the lack of ingredients (to me the fewer the better - give me natural baby!), the taste, the ability to change the consistency of the product (thin for drizzle over waffles, thick for with an apple), the ability to enjoy one of my favorite snacks with out the caloric guilt, and the taste. I had a friend who was hooked on JIF. She wouldn't EVER change, or so she thought. One try of the PB2 with her banana and she ditched the JIF and joined the PB2 train. I definitely recommend this product as a way to enjoy a guilty pleasure without all the guilt. The only thing is that the cost can get quite high if you eat PB2 and apples as much as I do.
When a co-worker first brought PB2 into work to share with us all, I have to admit I was skeptical and hesitant and thought she was a bit crazy. In just a couple of minutes though she had whipped us up a bit of the PB2 to try and I was hooked immediately. I am a huge peanut butter fan, HUGE - but because I am cautious about my caloric intake eating the regular PB isn't always the best option. Plus in some of these peanut butters you don't know what you are getting as far as ingredients go. The things that I love about PB2 is the lack of ingredients (to me the fewer the better - give me natural baby!), the taste, the ability to change the consistency of the product (thin for drizzle over waffles, thick for with an apple), the ability to enjoy one of my favorite snacks with out the caloric guilt, and the taste. I had a friend who was hooked on JIF. She wouldn't EVER change, or so she thought. One try of the PB2 with her banana and she ditched the JIF and joined the PB2 train. I definitely recommend this product as a way to enjoy a guilty pleasure without all the guilt. The only thing is that the cost can get quite high if you eat PB2 and apples as much as I do.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
Bysandra D.said...
These little packs are convenient and oh-so-tasty. They are the perfect snack size and come in many flavors. I like the honey almond butter with some apple slices. Good, healthy snack. In addition to loving their product, they are eco-conscious and always working to lessen their carbon footprint, support the local community, and are working with the non-GMO project. I'm a huge fan of Justin's.
These little packs are convenient and oh-so-tasty. They are the perfect snack size and come in many flavors. I like the honey almond butter with some apple slices. Good, healthy snack. In addition to loving their product, they are eco-conscious and always working to lessen their carbon footprint, support the local community, and are working with the non-GMO project. I'm a huge fan of Justin's.
Highlighted Review
ByGina A.said...
Wow, this almond butter is too good to be true. It has tons of protein in it, which fills me up! I love the taste too. It has awesome ingredients in it. and there is nothing about this I don't like. It's a healthy treat I love to have. I spread it on everything!!
Wow, this almond butter is too good to be true. It has tons of protein in it, which fills me up! I love the taste too. It has awesome ingredients in it. and there is nothing about this I don't like. It's a healthy treat I love to have. I spread it on everything!!
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
ByLauren J.said...
I am a huge peanut butter person so I was excited to try this when it first hit shelves but I really didn't expect to fall in love with it! Honestly I will never buy another kind or brand again. This stuff is incredible. It's so good that you want to eat it straight from the jar. Like seriously. It's that amazing. And another great thing is it's a healthier option. It comes with an added crunch which makes it all that more better. It also comes in regular flavor or honey roast. Me personally I do like both but I prefer the honey roast. Please if you haven't heard or tried it yet. Go out and get some. I promise you will wish you had sooner.
I am a huge peanut butter person so I was excited to try this when it first hit shelves but I really didn't expect to fall in love with it! Honestly I will never buy another kind or brand again. This stuff is incredible. It's so good that you want to eat it straight from the jar. Like seriously. It's that amazing. And another great thing is it's a healthier option. It comes with an added crunch which makes it all that more better. It also comes in regular flavor or honey roast. Me personally I do like both but I prefer the honey roast. Please if you haven't heard or tried it yet. Go out and get some. I promise you will wish you had sooner.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
ByAshley M.said...
I worked in a facility that was nut-free for years, so I was forced to adopt a "nut alternative" since I have a serious addiction to peanut-butter and jelly sandwiches. This spread certainly did not disappoint. It is not as sweet as regular peanut butter but it's thickness, color and taste greatly resemble that of peanut butter. My taste buds adapted quickly and now I actually prefer this- since it is actually a healthier choice than peanut butter. It is more expensive than regular peanut butter-- but that's a supply and demand issue. However I think it's worth the extra few dollars.
I worked in a facility that was nut-free for years, so I was forced to adopt a "nut alternative" since I have a serious addiction to peanut-butter and jelly sandwiches. This spread certainly did not disappoint. It is not as sweet as regular peanut butter but it's thickness, color and taste greatly resemble that of peanut butter. My taste buds adapted quickly and now I actually prefer this- since it is actually a healthier choice than peanut butter. It is more expensive than regular peanut butter-- but that's a supply and demand issue. However I think it's worth the extra few dollars.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
ByJoanna F.said...
It's raw AND organic and has a rich, decadent flavor. I add it to smoothies for extra protein, Asian stir fry and homemade cookies. It's a pantry staple in our house.
It's raw AND organic and has a rich, decadent flavor. I add it to smoothies for extra protein, Asian stir fry and homemade cookies. It's a pantry staple in our house.
Member Photos & Videos (3)
Highlighted Review
ByTrudy P.said...
I eat this straight out of the jar. It's a good balance of sweet and savoury. It's thick and creamy and I just eat it like dessert. Would probably make a good cake/cupcake 'icing'. The ingredients are not the best (considering how my nut butters usually are just blended nuts with oil added in sometimes), but this is so good that I don't even care. I find that Walmart sells this for the cheapest price compared to other stores.
I eat this straight out of the jar. It's a good balance of sweet and savoury. It's thick and creamy and I just eat it like dessert. Would probably make a good cake/cupcake 'icing'. The ingredients are not the best (considering how my nut butters usually are just blended nuts with oil added in sometimes), but this is so good that I don't even care. I find that Walmart sells this for the cheapest price compared to other stores.
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
Byoctavia M.said...
This almond butter has a nice roasted taste, smooth and is a great addition to my smoothies in the morning or on apples as a snack. This also works great for baking, I tried it in a gluten free cookie recipe and it worked great. I recommend.
This almond butter has a nice roasted taste, smooth and is a great addition to my smoothies in the morning or on apples as a snack. This also works great for baking, I tried it in a gluten free cookie recipe and it worked great. I recommend.
Highlighted Review
ByMichelle K.said...
Every single Nuts N More flavor is absolutely amazing! It also has some awesome nutritional stats! This is probably one of my favorite brands of nut butters. I have pretty good will power when it comes to foods, but with Nuts N More that totally goes out the window lol my other favorite flavors are the Birthday Cake and the Chocolate Maple Pretzel. Be warned, they are amazing, but TOTALLY addicting!
Every single Nuts N More flavor is absolutely amazing! It also has some awesome nutritional stats! This is probably one of my favorite brands of nut butters. I have pretty good will power when it comes to foods, but with Nuts N More that totally goes out the window lol my other favorite flavors are the Birthday Cake and the Chocolate Maple Pretzel. Be warned, they are amazing, but TOTALLY addicting!