The Best Cookie Dough Ice Creams

Based on 191,212 Influenster Reviews

Rich vanilla, chewy cookie bites and just the right amount of chocolate crunch – cookie dough ice cream is what dessert dreams are made of. We support working your way through EVERY ice cream brand if possible, but for those who are looking for a place to start, we have rounded up the top-rated cookie dough ice creams below. See what our members have to say and be sure to review your pick here on Influenster! 

Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Kristen M.
ByKristen M.said...
I think this is one of the first chocolate chip cookie dough ice creams that I really loved. It is so rich and delicious, while being affordable and easy to find in stores. I also like that the pint size is really easy to keep in my fridge and helps prevent completely overeating my ice cream. Since this is so rich it also makes it easier to eat only a little bit and be satisfied. But please understand that I have definitely cleared out a pint in one sitting. Let's be honest. I also love that this really has lots of big chunks of cookie dough throughout which makes it infinitely better than those versions that have 8 pieces of cookie dough in a whole pint. 
I think this is one of the first chocolate chip cookie dough ice creams that I really loved. It is so rich and delicious, while being affordable and easy to find in stores. I also like that the pint size is really easy to keep in my fridge and helps prevent completely overeating my ice cream. Since this is so rich it also makes it easier to eat only a little bit and be satisfied. But please understand that I have definitely cleared out a pint in one sitting. Let's be honest. I also love that this really has lots of big chunks of cookie dough throughout which makes it infinitely better than those versions that have 8 pieces of cookie dough in a whole pint. 
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Sonia S.
BySonia S.said...
This is my all-time favorite dairy free ice cream I have tasted this far! I’ve been dairy-free for several years and I’ve cream is one of my favorite things to enjoy. Halo top makes the ice cream the right consistency and I love that it is low in calories and added sugars! I never feel guilty eating this ice cream and I love the cookie dough chunks that are dispersed in there as well. I have already told all my friends about it and they are hooked now too even if they are not dairy-free!
This is my all-time favorite dairy free ice cream I have tasted this far! I’ve been dairy-free for several years and I’ve cream is one of my favorite things to enjoy. Halo top makes the ice cream the right consistency and I love that it is low in calories and added sugars! I never feel guilty eating this ice cream and I love the cookie dough chunks that are dispersed in there as well. I have already told all my friends about it and they are hooked now too even if they are not dairy-free!
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Charia M.
ByCharia M.said...
an OG classic with the right amount of quality cookie dough , can’t say i’ve had another cookie dough ice cream that was better than this one as Haagen Dazs has never disappointed me throughout the years. i know people say it’s expensive but i don’t mind the price for the quality you get let alone this saves you from an entire litre haha
an OG classic with the right amount of quality cookie dough , can’t say i’ve had another cookie dough ice cream that was better than this one as Haagen Dazs has never disappointed me throughout the years. i know people say it’s expensive but i don’t mind the price for the quality you get let alone this saves you from an entire litre haha
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Michelle H.
ByMichelle H.said...
SO GOOD! The caramel swirls in this are such a nice addition and really bring the flavors all together. This ice cream is a step up from the regular cookie dough flavors you find in other brands. Blue Bunny is a bit more pricey than other brands but the flavor is so good we will continue to buy!
SO GOOD! The caramel swirls in this are such a nice addition and really bring the flavors all together. This ice cream is a step up from the regular cookie dough flavors you find in other brands. Blue Bunny is a bit more pricey than other brands but the flavor is so good we will continue to buy!
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Wendy N.
ByWendy N.said...
My son loves this ice cream and wanted me to try it, and when I did I really did notice a difference from other brands I've had in the past. It's definitely the creamiest store-bought ice cream I can ever remember tasting. It was also more natural and "real" tasting than most others I've purchased myself. I am not a huge fan of ice cream in general and can just take it or leave it, but I think the quality of this brand impressed me enough to earn a review. I would definitely buy this for gatherings where ice-cream lovers are expected and mention it to those who I know love their ice cream.
My son loves this ice cream and wanted me to try it, and when I did I really did notice a difference from other brands I've had in the past. It's definitely the creamiest store-bought ice cream I can ever remember tasting. It was also more natural and "real" tasting than most others I've purchased myself. I am not a huge fan of ice cream in general and can just take it or leave it, but I think the quality of this brand impressed me enough to earn a review. I would definitely buy this for gatherings where ice-cream lovers are expected and mention it to those who I know love their ice cream.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Laura L.
ByLaura L.said...
This flavor is SO good! I have tried almost all of the Enlightened ice cream, but this is by far one of my favorites. I was looking for all the keto varieties they have,but this one sounded way to good not to try. It's chocolate ice cream with bits of chocolate chunks and cookie and brownie dough pieces. You can't go wrong with that combo. The dough pieces have the right amount of chew and the chocolate ice cream doesn't have any weird aftertaste or consistency. I've tried another low calorie ice cream before and the texture is like chalk and just not appealing to me. Enlightened is great! #enlightened #icecream #lowcal
This flavor is SO good! I have tried almost all of the Enlightened ice cream, but this is by far one of my favorites. I was looking for all the keto varieties they have,but this one sounded way to good not to try. It's chocolate ice cream with bits of chocolate chunks and cookie and brownie dough pieces. You can't go wrong with that combo. The dough pieces have the right amount of chew and the chocolate ice cream doesn't have any weird aftertaste or consistency. I've tried another low calorie ice cream before and the texture is like chalk and just not appealing to me. Enlightened is great! #enlightened #icecream #lowcal
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
Sandra S.
BySandra S.said...
I grew up on Friendlys. It was a family night out when I was younger so there’s a sense of nostalgia with their ice cream and it helps that it is absolutely delish! It’s been my go to ice cream during this quarantine.
I grew up on Friendlys. It was a family night out when I was younger so there’s a sense of nostalgia with their ice cream and it helps that it is absolutely delish! It’s been my go to ice cream during this quarantine.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Ariana I.
ByAriana I.said...
This brand has the best keto ice cream my husband and I tried so far! Flavors are really simple but good and creamy. I love that they don’t have the fake taste of artificial sweetener, honestly the only thing that could make them better would be a bigger selection of flavors, however even when we are not doing keto my husband and I still prefer this ice cream brand. Great job
This brand has the best keto ice cream my husband and I tried so far! Flavors are really simple but good and creamy. I love that they don’t have the fake taste of artificial sweetener, honestly the only thing that could make them better would be a bigger selection of flavors, however even when we are not doing keto my husband and I still prefer this ice cream brand. Great job
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
lauren V.
Bylauren V.said...
Edy's ice cream is always delicious. Chocolate chip cookie dough is my favorite. It's got good texture and consistency and I'd buy it over and over again. The single serve cups are great for when you want a late night treat!
Edy's ice cream is always delicious. Chocolate chip cookie dough is my favorite. It's got good texture and consistency and I'd buy it over and over again. The single serve cups are great for when you want a late night treat!
Member Photos & Videos (2)
Highlighted Review
Tara  W.
ByTara W.said...
I was impressed for “healthy” ice cream it was so good and creamy. I’ve had other brands and it’s not creamy to me. This was much more like traditional ice cream. The price was good. The cookie dough bits were good and there was a good amount not too little or too much. I would purchase again
I was impressed for “healthy” ice cream it was so good and creamy. I’ve had other brands and it’s not creamy to me. This was much more like traditional ice cream. The price was good. The cookie dough bits were good and there was a good amount not too little or too much. I would purchase again
Highlighted Review
Elizabeth R.
ByElizabeth R.said...
This ice cream is so thick and creamy you’d never believe it’s low fat. And you get really good chunks of cookie dough in it too, which are super tasty! I love that these come pre-portioned too, so you know exactly how much is in a serving.
This ice cream is so thick and creamy you’d never believe it’s low fat. And you get really good chunks of cookie dough in it too, which are super tasty! I love that these come pre-portioned too, so you know exactly how much is in a serving.