The Best Ben & Jerry’s Flavors: 55K Reviews

Based on 54,933 Influenster Reviews

If there are two men we know we can always count on for a solid evening it's Ben and Jerry. The namesakes of the delicious ice cream have some of the most tasty and innovative ice cream flavors around. Although it's beyond difficult for us to choose a favorite flavor, we did manage to find the best-tasting Ben & Jerry flavors based on thousands of Influenster reviews.

Check out which Ben & Jerry's flavors made the list, and be sure to share and review your favorite flavor!

Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Kelly G.
ByKelly G.said...
This is my all-time favorite Ben & Jerry's ice cream (and trust me, I've had A LOT of Ben & Jerry's! Actually, a lot of ice cream in general LOL). There are huge chucks of cookie dough and brownie pieces, covered in vanilla and chocolate ice cream. I like to let it sit and soften a little, so I don't have to really dig the pieces out. How anyone could give Half Baked less than an A boggles my mind, because it truly is number one if you like cookie dough, brownies, and ice cream!
This is my all-time favorite Ben & Jerry's ice cream (and trust me, I've had A LOT of Ben & Jerry's! Actually, a lot of ice cream in general LOL). There are huge chucks of cookie dough and brownie pieces, covered in vanilla and chocolate ice cream. I like to let it sit and soften a little, so I don't have to really dig the pieces out. How anyone could give Half Baked less than an A boggles my mind, because it truly is number one if you like cookie dough, brownies, and ice cream!
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Rebecca H.
ByRebecca H.said...
Ice cream is my go to snack and Ben & Jerry's is definitely an indulgent pick-me-up. Phish food is my favorite flavor because of the creamy marshmallow swirls throughout the rich chocolate ice cream. Life gets really good when you bite into a fish made of delicious chocolate. The different flavors of the ice cream mesh so well together that you can't put the spoon down. Even though Ben & Jerry's is more on the pricey side compared to other brands, I think you can definitely taste the supreme quality of the ingredients. Its worth the price tag when you want a tasty experience!
Ice cream is my go to snack and Ben & Jerry's is definitely an indulgent pick-me-up. Phish food is my favorite flavor because of the creamy marshmallow swirls throughout the rich chocolate ice cream. Life gets really good when you bite into a fish made of delicious chocolate. The different flavors of the ice cream mesh so well together that you can't put the spoon down. Even though Ben & Jerry's is more on the pricey side compared to other brands, I think you can definitely taste the supreme quality of the ingredients. Its worth the price tag when you want a tasty experience!
Highlighted Review
Rebecca M.
ByRebecca M.said...
Oh my word, this is one of my favorite Ben and Jerry's flavor. What I love about this is that it is so much better than the lower quality, fake looking green mint chocolate chip from other brands. It's white rather than green, has a much more real mint flavor (so many other brands taste way more artificial) Ben & Jerry's might cost more for a pint than some ice cream for a gallon but it is so worth it. The fact that they are fair trade and so high quality is a winner in my book
Oh my word, this is one of my favorite Ben and Jerry's flavor. What I love about this is that it is so much better than the lower quality, fake looking green mint chocolate chip from other brands. It's white rather than green, has a much more real mint flavor (so many other brands taste way more artificial) Ben & Jerry's might cost more for a pint than some ice cream for a gallon but it is so worth it. The fact that they are fair trade and so high quality is a winner in my book
Member Photos & Videos (1)
Highlighted Review
Alexis C.
ByAlexis C.said...
YUM YUM YUM. I love the crunch from the Heath Bar pieces and the coffee ice cream is so so much. It definitely is super sweet but I mean it's ice cream so it's expected. Honestly, I think we all know that any Ben & Jerry's ice cream is going to be amazing but this is one of my favorites!
YUM YUM YUM. I love the crunch from the Heath Bar pieces and the coffee ice cream is so so much. It definitely is super sweet but I mean it's ice cream so it's expected. Honestly, I think we all know that any Ben & Jerry's ice cream is going to be amazing but this is one of my favorites!
Member Photos & Videos (2)
Highlighted Review
Lauren N.
ByLauren N.said...
Americone Dream is such a perfect ice cream flavor! It's vanilla ice cream with caramel and pieces of fudge-covered waffle cone. It is not as "crazy" or as heavily flavored as other Ben&Jerry's flavors tend to be. It is mostly delicious vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered waffle cone pieces spread throughout. I'm a Ben&Jerry's addict and I've tried at least 30 flavors... I always come back to this one (and "the Tonight Dough"!). I recommend this flavor if: you like vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce, you like waffle cones, or you are a human being.
Americone Dream is such a perfect ice cream flavor! It's vanilla ice cream with caramel and pieces of fudge-covered waffle cone. It is not as "crazy" or as heavily flavored as other Ben&Jerry's flavors tend to be. It is mostly delicious vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered waffle cone pieces spread throughout. I'm a Ben&Jerry's addict and I've tried at least 30 flavors... I always come back to this one (and "the Tonight Dough"!). I recommend this flavor if: you like vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce, you like waffle cones, or you are a human being.
Highlighted Review
Amanda G.
ByAmanda G.said...
Seriously, you HAVE to try this! It is not only the BEST flavor it is the best made red velvet cake ice cream by far! It has chunks of cake and icing mixed into vanilla ice cream!!! I am drooling just thinking about it! Go..what are you waiting for...GO!!!
Seriously, you HAVE to try this! It is not only the BEST flavor it is the best made red velvet cake ice cream by far! It has chunks of cake and icing mixed into vanilla ice cream!!! I am drooling just thinking about it! Go..what are you waiting for...GO!!!
Member Photos & Videos (2)
Highlighted Review
Janie A.
ByJanie A.said...
This is my most favorite ice cream by Ben & Jerry's since I was a child, I love everything to the lightly sweet cherry ice cream to the big chunks of black cherries and chocolate! It's perfect for just a night with the girls or just a night in by yourself. Love, love, love this ice cream! ❤️🍒🍫🍨
This is my most favorite ice cream by Ben & Jerry's since I was a child, I love everything to the lightly sweet cherry ice cream to the big chunks of black cherries and chocolate! It's perfect for just a night with the girls or just a night in by yourself. Love, love, love this ice cream! ❤️🍒🍫🍨