I have nothing bad to say about this product! It really lasts on my lids, and doesn't budge! When using this product, it's best to have a primer underneath, eye shadow optional. I use that black color for bold winged liner, and it stays in place all day, no need to touch up! The gel formula is really great over all, I've even used it once or twice as a black lipstick and woaaaahhhh it was so amazing! Not to mention that for how small of a pot of product there is, it really lasts for a long time, and you don't need to dig at it, because the product is so creamy and soft before it dries down, that you only need to gently dip your brush into it to get reaaally good pigment. ALSO! I don't know if they sell the eyeliner pots individually without the brush, but if you see one with the eyeliner brush in the packaging it, BUY IT! The brush is actually really good for eyeliner, and it's super precise! I LOVE this product so much!