Drugstore Dupes for Benefit's Roller Lash Mascara

Based on 94,504 Influenster Reviews

Everyone loves a little length and lift with their mascara. And there's hardly a better formula around than Benefit's Roller Lash. With more than 9,800+ reviews as well as an Influenster approval rating of 4.5 stars, this is one mascara that lives up to the hype. And although it's a top pick for makeup lovers, it packs a bit of a price tag punch. At $24, this is a bit of a splurge item for sure. 

But don't worry! You can get a quality mascara for half the price. Influensters have found a number of volumizing, lifting, and lengthening mascaras right at your local drugstore. To see which mascaras are making their lashes pop, keep reading! One of these might just be your new perfect dupe for Benefit's Roller Lash mascara!

Member Photos & Videos (3)
Highlighted Review
Sonya G.
BySonya G.said...
This is hands down my favorite drug store mascara. It's AMAZING and so worth the price! It makes your lashes so much longer and so much more voluminous. It doesn't flake or clump. I always get compliments on how long my eyelashes are when I wear this mascara. I prefer this to my high end mascaras like They're Real. I have absolutely no complaints about this mascara and will definitely repurchase when I run out. When I use other mascaras I find myself having to do lots of coats, and I usually use 2 mascaras together. However, with this you don't need anything else and you'll see an immediate difference after just one swipe. It's perfect for traveling, I recently took it on vacation because it's so lightweight and does the job of multiple mascaras. If you need a new mascara buy this!
This is hands down my favorite drug store mascara. It's AMAZING and so worth the price! It makes your lashes so much longer and so much more voluminous. It doesn't flake or clump. I always get compliments on how long my eyelashes are when I wear this mascara. I prefer this to my high end mascaras like They're Real. I have absolutely no complaints about this mascara and will definitely repurchase when I run out. When I use other mascaras I find myself having to do lots of coats, and I usually use 2 mascaras together. However, with this you don't need anything else and you'll see an immediate difference after just one swipe. It's perfect for traveling, I recently took it on vacation because it's so lightweight and does the job of multiple mascaras. If you need a new mascara buy this!
Member Photos & Videos (3)
Highlighted Review
Katie H.
ByKatie H.said...
This is my all time favorite mascara from Maybelline. The brush is plastic bristled with a long outside curve and short bristles inside the curve. It comes in a pearl pink tube. There are other versions of Lash Sensational with different brushes but the original version is by far the best. Not being a typical spoolie, the brush can take some getting used to but it works great. The formula is a wetter formula than say Full N Soft. It does a great job curling the lashes and making them dark. It doesn't smudge or flake and lasts all day. It can be easily removed with a gentle rub and some warm water or a regular makeup remover. It is easy to build up coats while the product is still damp and when it dries it doesn't get hard or brittle. Have used several tubes of this mascara and will definitely continue purchasing this product.
This is my all time favorite mascara from Maybelline. The brush is plastic bristled with a long outside curve and short bristles inside the curve. It comes in a pearl pink tube. There are other versions of Lash Sensational with different brushes but the original version is by far the best. Not being a typical spoolie, the brush can take some getting used to but it works great. The formula is a wetter formula than say Full N Soft. It does a great job curling the lashes and making them dark. It doesn't smudge or flake and lasts all day. It can be easily removed with a gentle rub and some warm water or a regular makeup remover. It is easy to build up coats while the product is still damp and when it dries it doesn't get hard or brittle. Have used several tubes of this mascara and will definitely continue purchasing this product.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Angie H.
ByAngie H.said...
I was very excited to try the Full Lash which promised to make my eyelashes softer and much fuller... and I really liked the pink packaging. I should never pick a product by packaging, but sometimes I just can't resist! Snicker away, you know at least once you have done the same! Mascara is the one thing I always apply before going out. I can go without putting anything else on, and I am content. But mascara I can not. You would be surprised how drastically your face can change with just mascara. Bring our eyes to life! I have tried many mascara's over the years, and Covergirl is one of the best on the market. Before I share with you what I think about the new Covergirl Full Lash Bloom Mascara, I want to share what I first noticed when I opened it. I absolutely love this! The brush is NOT in the mascara pre-purchase! This is exactly how any brand new mascara should come. Being a Mom & a blogger means that evenings are generally spent at home, so I chose the Covergirl Full Lash Bloom because it's meant for a soft day time look. Throughout the day I am one of those people touching their eyes. Not sure why but I'm always doing it. My eyes lashes did feel much softer, didn't feel like I was even wearing mascara. I did find that if I am not careful it does clump. BUT If I was concerned about that I would have chosen the Clump Crusher mascara. If you are looking for a very subtle soft look, this is the mascara to check out. Your lashes will be full, soft and noticeably gorgeous!
I was very excited to try the Full Lash which promised to make my eyelashes softer and much fuller... and I really liked the pink packaging. I should never pick a product by packaging, but sometimes I just can't resist! Snicker away, you know at least once you have done the same! Mascara is the one thing I always apply before going out. I can go without putting anything else on, and I am content. But mascara I can not. You would be surprised how drastically your face can change with just mascara. Bring our eyes to life! I have tried many mascara's over the years, and Covergirl is one of the best on the market. Before I share with you what I think about the new Covergirl Full Lash Bloom Mascara, I want to share what I first noticed when I opened it. I absolutely love this! The brush is NOT in the mascara pre-purchase! This is exactly how any brand new mascara should come. Being a Mom & a blogger means that evenings are generally spent at home, so I chose the Covergirl Full Lash Bloom because it's meant for a soft day time look. Throughout the day I am one of those people touching their eyes. Not sure why but I'm always doing it. My eyes lashes did feel much softer, didn't feel like I was even wearing mascara. I did find that if I am not careful it does clump. BUT If I was concerned about that I would have chosen the Clump Crusher mascara. If you are looking for a very subtle soft look, this is the mascara to check out. Your lashes will be full, soft and noticeably gorgeous!
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Carrielle S.
ByCarrielle S.said...
Most mascaras don't give my lashes enough oomph or deliver on the claims they make. The Colossal Big Shot Mascara is one that finally does. My lashes look fuller, longer and overall more glam than with previous mascaras I've tried. I love how it doesn't clump after two coats. It stayed on really well throughout the day even though it's washable. It didn't smudge or run. The brush can be tricky to navigate as first, however, once you get the hang of it, you will be a fan of the applicator. Overall, I was really impressed by the mascara. It took me a couple applications to really see all the benefits it provided. If you like Maybelline Falsies, you will love this one too! Hoping for a waterproof version in the future. I received these products free or complimentary from Influenster for testing purposes. All opinions are my own.
Most mascaras don't give my lashes enough oomph or deliver on the claims they make. The Colossal Big Shot Mascara is one that finally does. My lashes look fuller, longer and overall more glam than with previous mascaras I've tried. I love how it doesn't clump after two coats. It stayed on really well throughout the day even though it's washable. It didn't smudge or run. The brush can be tricky to navigate as first, however, once you get the hang of it, you will be a fan of the applicator. Overall, I was really impressed by the mascara. It took me a couple applications to really see all the benefits it provided. If you like Maybelline Falsies, you will love this one too! Hoping for a waterproof version in the future. I received these products free or complimentary from Influenster for testing purposes. All opinions are my own.
Member Photos & Videos (4)
Highlighted Review
Cailee M.
ByCailee M.said...
One of my absolute favorite mascaras! I've gone through countless tubes of Carbon Black and Brown Black throughout the years. The one I'm reviewing is the one with a straight brush, NOT the curved spoon brush. Now, with this, I definitely think a bit of aging does well to its performance. After a few weeks of it being opened, the formula thickens up nicely. When first opened, it feels slippery and wet when applied, and takes a bit longer to dry. None of my tubes have dried out quickly, compared to a lot of other mascaras. I already have long, thick lashes, so really, I think I'm one of the lucky ones when I say that I'm just not picky when it comes to mascara. As long as a mascara doesn't make my lashes stick straight out (even when they're curled) or clump them up beyond recognition, and as long as it has good staying power, and doesn't flake, I'm set with anything! This gives me great volume and length with just one coat. People generally ask me if I have falsies on. It grabs every one of my lashes, and makes them look nice and separated. The one thing I will say is that it doesn't hold a curl extremely well. Its performance on that is a bit average. Stays on most of the day without flaking (it fades slightly as the day goes on, but it never ends up anywhere on my face). For the most part, I love this mascara to pieces, and I will continue to buy it!
One of my absolute favorite mascaras! I've gone through countless tubes of Carbon Black and Brown Black throughout the years. The one I'm reviewing is the one with a straight brush, NOT the curved spoon brush. Now, with this, I definitely think a bit of aging does well to its performance. After a few weeks of it being opened, the formula thickens up nicely. When first opened, it feels slippery and wet when applied, and takes a bit longer to dry. None of my tubes have dried out quickly, compared to a lot of other mascaras. I already have long, thick lashes, so really, I think I'm one of the lucky ones when I say that I'm just not picky when it comes to mascara. As long as a mascara doesn't make my lashes stick straight out (even when they're curled) or clump them up beyond recognition, and as long as it has good staying power, and doesn't flake, I'm set with anything! This gives me great volume and length with just one coat. People generally ask me if I have falsies on. It grabs every one of my lashes, and makes them look nice and separated. The one thing I will say is that it doesn't hold a curl extremely well. Its performance on that is a bit average. Stays on most of the day without flaking (it fades slightly as the day goes on, but it never ends up anywhere on my face). For the most part, I love this mascara to pieces, and I will continue to buy it!