Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

The Best Prestige Brow Pencils: 144K Reviews
Beauty Awards

The Best Prestige Brow Pencils: 144K Reviews

Based on 143,964 Influenster Reviews

Over plucked eyebrows don't have to be a horrible nightmare. All you need is the help of a great brow pencil to fill in gaps and give your brows some volume. We've found the best brow pencils for you to do just that.

Check out this list of the top-rated brow pencils, based on more than 127K Influenster reviews.

18
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz®
BY ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS
4.6 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars77%
  • 4 Stars17%
  • 3 Stars4%
  • 2 Stars1%
  • 1 Star0%
4.7 / 5 (10,965 reviews)
Buy on Sephora for $21.00
Influenster Beauty Awards Winner 2016
Highlighted Review
Pam H. said...
This and dip brow are two of my main staple brow products of all time. I started off using dip brow, but found that it was easy to go overboard and it took a bit of time to apply. So I decided to try out the brow whiz because there are some days I just don't have the time to be spending on my brows. Turns out I've fallen in love with this product, I would dare even say that I like it more than my dip brow.

It's super easy to apply since it is in a twist up pencil form with a spoolie on the other end; no need to worry about a brush or pencil sharpener. The formula isn't waterproof like the dip brow, but it is long lasting. I've heard complaints of people saying that it pulls out their brow hairs, but I have never had that problem. My favorite thing about it is that it leaves your with beautifully shaped, but still natural looking brows. Because it has a fine point end, when applied in short strokes it mimics the look of brow hairs. You can also build up product for a stronger brow. ...read more
From Our Members
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz® uploaded by Julie D.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz® uploaded by Yahaira D.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz® uploaded by Madeline M.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz® uploaded by Skyler S.
See All Photos & Videos
Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil
BY BENEFIT COSMETICS
4.5 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars68%
  • 4 Stars23%
  • 3 Stars7%
  • 2 Stars2%
  • 1 Star1%
4.5 / 5 (2,713 reviews)
Buy on Sephora for $24.00
Highlighted Review
Abygail B.Abygail B. said...
I seriously don't know what I was doing with my brows before I got this product. The shape of the pencil is perfect for doing the tips of my brows and the inner corners. The colour matches my brows very well- I have dark brown hair and I got number 5. I also like not having to clean a brush. It's also retractable so you don't have to worry about sharpening or breaking the tip. I like how there's a spoolie on the other end too. Literally amazing if you're lazy or in a rush. You do have to press a little harder because it's a pencil, not a gel, but the pencil is more forgiving than a gel product if you make a mistake. My brows last all day and don't smudge easily, however, my brow hairs don't get pulled out when I try to remove the product, like they have with other brow products I have tried. I didn't buy a primer and I don't think it's really necessary unless your brow hairs are really long and tend to move around a lot. The product doesn't really hold your brow hairs in place, but I find it isn't an issue for me. The packaging is also adorable, I'm hooked! ...read more
From Our Members
Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil uploaded by Samantha C.
Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil uploaded by Aleciram H.
Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil uploaded by Lyndsay D.
Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil uploaded by Lyndsay D.
See All Photos & Videos
25% OFF REDEEM.
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Waterproof Perfector
BY IT COSMETICS
4.3 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars60%
  • 4 Stars25%
  • 3 Stars10%
  • 2 Stars3%
  • 1 Star2%
4.4 / 5 (2,684 reviews)
Buy on Jet.com for $19.94
Highlighted Review
Brooke L.Brooke L. said...
I CANNOT LIVE WITHOUT THIS!!! for some unknown reason, my eyebrows HATE ME!! and they have stopped growing nice and even and full.... So now, I have these crazy sparse sad brows... UNTIL I stumbled across this! I was a complete skeptic at first thinking my hair was way to dark and it would NEVER match, but I was soooo wrong! It matches! The spoolie is perfect in size and strength (its not cheap and falling apart) and the tip is flat, so you can make thin hairlike lines. Which is important unless you are a fan of the marker look....(I'm not) I ran out on accident (didn't order soon enough) and tried others while waiting for this to come and nothing compared! I recommend this to anyone wanting natural looking brows that just need a little filling out! My only complaint is that when I sweat it comes off, but hey, so does every other make up in the world so I still give it 5 stars! ...read more
From Our Members
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Waterproof Perfector uploaded by April W.
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Waterproof Perfector uploaded by Trista N.
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Waterproof Perfector uploaded by Ynez B.
IT Cosmetics Brow Power Waterproof Perfector uploaded by Lisa m.
See All Photos & Videos
Benefit Precisely My Brows
BY BENEFIT COSMETICS
4.6 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars74%
  • 4 Stars19%
  • 3 Stars5%
  • 2 Stars1%
  • 1 Star0%
4.6 / 5 (1,974 reviews)
Buy on Sephora for $24.00
Highlighted Review
Hannah C.Hannah C. said...
I use this product EVERY. DAY. I honestly will never use another product. It's pricey, but there is no alternative to me. Even Anastasia Beverly Hills products come second to Benefit. The color selection matches so many shades and the convenience is beyond belief. With similarly packaged products. I have experienced the caps for either the spoolie or the pencil breaking or not staying on after some time. Not only has the packaging lasted, it's adorable and convenient. The consistency is creamy and the product is easy to apply. It's also easy to blend if you're going for a more natural look, such as myself. It lasts forever! I've been using the same pencil, daily, since August 14th and I have used just over half of it. This product is worth EVERY penny! ...read more
From Our Members
Benefit Precisely My Brows uploaded by Sarah L.
Benefit Precisely My Brows uploaded by xo j.
Benefit Precisely My Brows uploaded by malisa p.
Benefit Precisely My Brows uploaded by Whitney L.
See All Photos & Videos
25% OFF REDEEM.
Chella Luscious Brow Color Pencil
BY CHELLA
4.6 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars75%
  • 4 Stars17%
  • 3 Stars7%
  • 2 Stars1%
  • 1 Star0%
4.7 / 5 (126 reviews)
Buy on Amazon for $18.00
Highlighted Review
Michelle S.Michelle S. said...
I have this pencil in the colour taupe, which I was surprised to find worked great for me, despite my having dark brown hair. The micro thin size of the pencil is fantastic for small brush strokes that look like hair to fill in thinner areas of your brows, and the size is also optimal for precision (like for the tail of the brow.) EVERYONE raves about Anastasia Beverly Hills' Brow Wiz pencil, which I like a lot as well, but I find myself reaching for Chella more often. Plus the Chella pencil is less expensive, so bonus! It doesn't have a spoolie attached to the pencil the way the ABH Brow Wiz does, but that doesn't matter for me as I have a spoolie separately in my toolkit. ...read more
From Our Members
Chella Luscious Brow Color Pencil uploaded by Breanna W.
Chella Luscious Brow Color Pencil uploaded by Andrea C.
Chella Luscious Brow Color Pencil uploaded by Miranda F.
Chella Luscious Brow Color Pencil uploaded by Ana A.
See All Photos & Videos
Lancôme Le Crayon Poudre Powder Pencil for the Brows
BY LANCÔME
4.5 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars67%
  • 4 Stars23%
  • 3 Stars7%
  • 2 Stars2%
  • 1 Star1%
4.6 / 5 (129 reviews)
Buy on Sephora for $26.50
Highlighted Review
Elizabeth W.Elizabeth W. said...
Let me just say that I didn't start living until I discovered this pencil! I have hardly any hairs on my eyebrows, so I basically have to draw onto my skin. Anyone who has this problem knows that it's hard to find any crayon that doesn't darken throughout the day as your skin's natural oils come through.

The colors offered are very natural and the brush helps to lighten your brows if you put them on too heavy/too dark. The staying power of this is amazing. It wears 12+ hours. Fantastic if you need brows and don't want to make it look like yours are fake. A++ to Lancome for this! ...read more
From Our Members
Lancôme Le Crayon Poudre Powder Pencil for the Brows uploaded by Elizabeth W.
Lancôme Le Crayon Poudre Powder Pencil for the Brows uploaded by Diana V.
FREE SHIPPING REDEEM.

Join now to gain access to over 20 million product reviews, free full size samples, and the latest product news.

Get Started

Are you a Brand or Agency? Contact Us