I have the Roses version of this palette. It really is a copy of Naked 3 at a fraction of the price. The pigment was great when I swatched it on my fingers but when I wore it, some colors were hit or miss. However, due to the price, I still would recommend. Naked colors at a way better price! Just don't expect the quality to be as good. Still a pretty set.
I was very disappointed with the pigment of this shadow palette. I've never used the Physicians Formula brand before but had heard good things about it. Too bad bc of these shadows, this will be my first and last experience. The colors barely showed on my lids and if they did, didn't last long. I do not recommend.